Okay I will give this a shot. If that's the case, GIMP might actually do the same since I couldn't get its BMPs to work either. What's weird though is why is it red and green on Vogtinator's PC and my phone but proper b/w on my PC and DJ's ?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dcd96/dcd96ca2bf23a15fef0f953b5bf1e2d66e502b55" alt="Huh? ???"
Maybe the format needs a palette to be specified which ImageMagick didn't do or something.