0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
*sigh*Looks like a new website has jumped the language wars bandwaggon now (although it's not really the first time it happens, since Axe was criticized several times there too): http://tiplanet.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=43&t=13427&p=152729#p152729nDealOrNoDeal is getting bashed for using Ndless instead of Lua.
Although I can understand the reasons, isn't the choice of a language for a game the author's choice that isn't being respected in there?
One thing for sure, TI-Planet has lost an user (and possibly an entire author profile) until this stops, because I will never ever supports a website that advocates deliberate langage wars that only divides the TI community.
you can easily take stuff out of context and make you say you hate Ndless.
Quote from: Juju on November 21, 2013, 11:55:33 amyou can easily take stuff out of context and make you say you hate Ndless.You forgot "pour ce type de jeu".
And keep in mind not everyone have hardware J/K calcs and if someone wants Ndless, you can easily avoid them by buying second hand.
But the "toutefois" word shows that Critor is not bashing the game, but saying "everything is awesome except that little thing".Quote from: Juju on November 21, 2013, 11:55:33 amAnd keep in mind not everyone have hardware J/K calcs and if someone wants Ndless, you can easily avoid them by buying second hand.But that is becaus you know it, but not everyone knows that. A lot of people on TI Planet are asking "how do I downgrade from 3.2.4" and answer J when we ask "what is your hardware revision ?", because they weren't aware of all those protections.
Also, as mentionned mdr1, Critor doesn't hate Ndless (or he would have done mViewer in TI Basic), but just said that a non ressource-expensive game couls have been done in Lua, even though it would have been a lot slower to load with all those graphics, a lot bigger in size, and possibly not fun to code for AJOrians if he prefers coding in C over Lua. So it was just a "could have been possible to", not a "should never have happened".
Même si ce n'était pas méchant, et que c'était juste un petit regret, le soulignement d'une petite tache verte sur le tableau rose, ça fait quand même un peu "c'est dommage que personne ne pourra y jouer alors qu'ils auraient pu, franchement, sur un jeu comme ça" (en moins violent évidemment). Je ne dis pas que c'est faux, encore une fois, juste que moi, si j'étais AJOrians et si je lisais ça, je me dirais "bon ben personne n'y jouera, j'arrête de le coder, et je le refais pas en Lua, j'ai pas envie de le recoder", et lors de mon prochain jeu, je me dirais "vais pas le faire en C, on va me le 'reprocher' (même si ce n'est pas un reproche), mais pas en Lua non plus ça va être moins beau" et finalement je vais arrêter de coder.
To be clearer than the last paragraph of critor's post: admins, make DJ_O cool down, or face reduced newsing activity by critor & Adriweb (and thereby reduced activity of your entire board). Lower activity due to a single person out of his mind is the last thing the community needs, needless to say.